The Plight of Child Actors: Challenges, Laws & Hopeful Reforms

A Legacy in Lights and Shadows: The History of Child Actors

The role of child performers has been central to the entertainment industry since its inception, tracing roots to the earliest days of silent films and vaudeville stages. The “star child” archetype—embodied by figures like Jackie Coogan, Baby Peggy (Diana Serra Cary), and the entire Watson family—helped cement children as fixtures on the silver screen, their talents captivating both domestic and international audiences. The Watson siblings alone appeared in over a thousand films, working with Hollywood’s greatest legends. While their stories highlight camaraderie and nostalgia, the industry’s glitter has long masked an undercurrent of exploitation and hardship for its youngest stars.

During the silent era and into the “talkies,” child actors were invaluable for their authenticity, capacity to evoke emotion, and ability to draw crowds. Studios like MGM, Fox, and Pathe Exchange capitalized on their appeal, investing heavily in child-centric features and meticulously curated public images. Shirley Temple in particular, with her signature curls and irrepressible positivity, became a cultural avatar during the Great Depression, offering hope and joy to struggling generations.

But this same era also bore witness to foundational cracks in the system. Young stars were treated as commodities, bound to grueling contracts, expected to perform adult-level labor, and granted little agency over their lives or finances. The celebratory narratives often omitted the persistent pressure, instability, and vulnerability felt behind the curtains—and the perils of growing up “on stage,” scrutinized by millions yet seldom truly seen.

The Evolving Legal Framework: From Coogan’s Case to the Digital Age

Early Exploitation and the Birth of Legal Protections

The exploitation of child actors reached a critical inflection point in 1938, when Jackie Coogan—the cherubic star of Charlie Chaplin’s “The Kid”—discovered that his mother and stepfather had spent his childhood fortune of over $4 million, leaving him with only $126,000 after legal fees. Coogan sued, but the court found that under then-existing law, all earnings belonged to the parents. Outrage over this scandal prompted the California legislature to pass the pioneering California Child Actor’s Bill (Coogan Law) in 1939, mandating judges to set aside a portion of a child actor’s income in trust until they reached adulthood.

Despite good intentions, early versions of the Coogan Law were rife with loopholes. Only court-approved contracts qualified, discretionary percentages could still be manipulated, and parents retained considerable control over the remainder of their child’s income. Notable stars such as Judy Garland and Shirley Temple continued to suffer financial mismanagement, demonstrating the insufficiency of sporadic reforms.

The Modern Framework: Expanding Protections and Closing Loopholes

Decades of advocacy by affected performers, unions, and child rights activists led to critical revisions. By 2000, amendments to the Coogan Law mandated that at least 15% of a child’s gross earnings be placed in a blocked trust account—untouchable until age 18 and legally recognized as the child’s sole property, not the family’s. However, even these advances left 85% of a child’s income unprotected from parental misuse or mismanagement, and the guardians themselves often occupied conflicted roles—as both caretakers and managers.

Current variations exist state-by-state. States such as New York, Illinois, Louisiana, and New Mexico have enacted similar trust account statutes, but at least 17 states still lack dedicated laws for child entertainers, relying only on generic labor statutes of widely varying adequacy.

Table: State Requirements for Child Performer Trust Accounts (Selected States)

State	Account Required	Percentage Withheld	Notes
California	Yes	15%	Blocked “Coogan Account”; must be opened before work begins
New York	Yes	15%	UTMA/UGMA compliant account; applies to gross earnings
Illinois	Yes	15%	Applies to performing arts/vlogging; effective 2024 law change
Louisiana	Yes	15%	Blocked trust account; must be established within 30 days
New Mexico	Yes (conditional)	15%	Applies if earning > $1,000 per contract
Other States	Various/apply	N/A	Many have no statutory requirement or only partial protections

A special note must be made of court-ordered contract approval requirements, the variety in work permit processes, differences in education/tutoring mandates, and oversight of on-set safety/welfare personnel—all of which differ substantially by jurisdiction and strongly affect a child’s day-to-day experience.

Federal Regulations and Persistent Gaps

At the national level, the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) of 1938 continues to exempt child entertainers from federal child labor protections. Instead, it leaves regulation largely to the states, creating a regulatory “patchwork” where child actors in many places may find themselves precariously protected at best. The FLSA further allows children employed by their parents to bypass child labor standards entirely—a dangerous loophole for vulnerable young earners.

Only in recent years, in response to changing cultural norms and high-profile cases of abuse or financial manipulation, have various states and advocacy organizations called for federal standards or broad legislative reform reaching into the emergent territory of social media—a space where “kidfluencers” reign but legal safeguards are less evolved.

The Psychological and Social Impacts of Early Fame

Developmental Consequences of Life in the Spotlight

While legislative focus has historically centered on the financial exploitation of child actors, modern academic and clinical research underscores the psychological, developmental, and social depth of their plight. Young performers are expected to deliver adult-caliber work under intense scrutiny, while navigating childhood milestones in the glare of public adulation and criticism. The result is a complex web of emotional risks:

Disturbed Identity Formation: Child actors often struggle to distinguish their authentic selves from their public persona, leading to identity confusion, alienation, and “imposter syndrome”.
Attachment Wounds: The blurring of affection with applause—and the replacement of attuned caregiving with transactional relationships—disrupts healthy child development, fueling later insecurity and difficulty in sustaining adult relationships.
Performance Pressure and Burnout: Ongoing pressure to excel breeds relentless anxiety, perfectionism, and chronic stress. Extended work hours and high expectations are fundamentally at odds with the natural rhythms of childhood development.
Isolation: Unusual routines, travel, and estrangement from typical peer groups hinder socialization. This can leave young stars feeling profoundly alone, often unable to relate to non-industry friends and subject to bullying or exclusion in traditional school settings.

Mental health struggles—manifesting as anxiety, depression, eating disorders, addictive behaviors, and even dissociation—frequently emerge, sometimes at shockingly young ages. As River Phoenix lamented, “I never had a childhood. I was performing when other kids were playing”.

Table: Common Psychological and Social Impacts on Child Actors

Impact	Description/Examples
Identity Diffusion	Difficulty separating public image from self
Attachment Insecurity	Loss of trust, conditional approval, parental role confusion
Emotional and Behavioral Issues	Anxiety, depression, perfectionism, substance abuse
Academic Challenges	Irregular schooling, inconsistent learning environments
Peer Isolation	Loss of regular friends, bullying, lack of normal socialization
Powerless/Exploited Feeling	Vulnerability to adult power dynamics, abuse, or manipulation

Some former child stars, like Jennette McCurdy (“I’m Glad My Mom Died”) and Alyson Stoner, have shed light on the trauma of being commodified, parental role confusion, and the lack of support for genuine healing. New research links early stardom’s upheaval with lifelong impacts, including elevated risk for substance use, relationship difficulties, and even reduced lifespan.

Education: Rights, Obstacles, and Patchwork Solutions

On-Set Schooling and Academic Continuity

The balancing act between career and education remains fraught for most child actors. Though legal requirements in production hubs like California and New York enforce compulsory education, work-hour caps, and on-set tutoring (usually 3+ hours per day during shoots), their effectiveness varies by production, state, and individual diligence. In some regions, the presence of certified studio teachers—charged with safeguarding both academics and child welfare—is mandatory; elsewhere, the responsibility falls more loosely on parents or sometimes goes overlooked altogether.

Despite such measures, practical realities mean that child actors:

Frequently experience interrupted or inconsistent schooling
Struggle to keep up with peers academically
Suffer from academic “gaps” and social marginalization upon return to traditional schools
Miss out on extracurricular opportunities and normal school milestones

Technological advances have allowed for increased use of online learning, hybrid schooling, or home-schooling adaptations, but these too have limitations in terms of socialization and quality, and depend heavily on parental resources, advocacy, and a child’s own motivation. When legal compliance becomes a box-checking exercise rather than a robust educational commitment, true academic and personal development suffers.

The Consequence: Educational Shortfalls and Vulnerability

For many, education provides a critical safety net—a path for life after the inevitable unpredictability of show business. Without a solid academic foundation, former child actors may encounter difficulties transitioning to adult careers outside entertainment, compounding feelings of loss or purposelessness if the spotlight fades.

Parents, tutors, and social services are urged to treat academic needs as non-negotiable, advocating for standardized guidelines and quality assurance across all states and productions—not merely minimal adherence to legal statutes.

Financial Exploitation: Safeguards and Persistent Loopholes

The Coogan Act and Its Limits

The Coogan Act and its counterparts represent monumental progress in protecting child actors’ financial interests. By requiring a portion of income to be deposited in blocked trust accounts (minimum 15% in most states currently), today’s laws have significantly reduced the frequency of catastrophic losses suffered by generations past (notably Jackie Coogan, Shirley Temple, Judy Garland, and Gary Coleman).

Yet, critical loopholes remain:

Only a portion of earnings is protected; the remainder is typically managed—and too often spent—by parents or guardians, some of whom depend on the child’s earnings to support the entire family.
Irresponsible or ill-equipped trustees can mishandle even the protected funds, as seen in real-life cases where parents have misappropriated, failed to account for, or even stolen from their child’s trust.
Limited recourse for children: Lawsuits against parents are still rare, due to psychological and legal barriers as well as the complexity of family relationships.
Administrative gaps: Deposits can be delayed, misplaced, or go unmonitored, leaving children vulnerable to inadvertent errors or malfeasance by studios, payroll companies, or financial institutions.

While strong, the protective net is not impermeable. The patchwork of state-level regulations—where some states offer robust Coogan-style trust laws and others offer none—only exacerbates the issue.

The Rise of Child Influencers: A Modern Frontier of Exploitation

With the explosion of kid-centric social media—YouTube, TikTok, Instagram—child “influencers” (“kidfluencers”) now grace screens worldwide, amassing viewership and sponsorships at a scale rivaling traditional film and TV stars. Yet, because most existing labor laws were drafted before the era of digital content creation, kidfluencers are frequently excluded from even minimal legal protections.

Examples abound of family vloggers or young social media personalities whose earning power is controlled entirely by parents, who may or may not act in the child’s best interests. The recent Ruby Franke and Piper Rockelle scandals have starkly demonstrated the harm that can result when lines between caregiver, manager, and legal guardian blur without oversight.

Emerging legislative reforms, such as Illinois S.B. 3646 (2024), California A.B. 1880 (2024), Minnesota H.F. 3488 (2024; effective 2025), and Utah H.B. 322 (2025), now aim to close these gaps by requiring trust accounts, record-keeping, and even allowing children to request removal of content from the internet once they reach adulthood. However, such reforms are new, and their enforceability and practical impact are still being tested.

Industry Practices: Contracts, Safety, and Working Conditions

Work Permits and Contracts

All professional productions are legally required to obtain work permits for every child actor, with requirements often including health verification, parental consent, proof of academic readiness, and, increasingly, proof of a trust account established in the child’s name. However, in some states, loopholes allow productions to circumvent these requirements under specific circumstances, or for non-traditional types of performances (including some reality TV and internet media).

A critical industry concern remains contracts with minors: children, by law, lack the capacity to enter binding contracts. To mitigate the risk of child stars “disaffirming” agreements (i.e., walking away from obligations without penalty), studios routinely seek judicial approval, which—while binding the child to the contract—can sometimes lead to binding them to multi-year commitments with little recourse for abuse or undue pressure.

On-Set Supervision, Hours, and Safety Measures

Unions (notably, SAG-AFTRA) and leading industry guilds stipulate comprehensive standards for child safety:

Strict caps on daily and weekly hours on set (ranging by age—e.g., infants: 20 minutes/day; 7-year-olds: 4-6 hours/day; teens: up to 10 hours/day).
Mandatory rest, meal, and recreation breaks, plus a 12-hour turnaround between workdays.
Supervision at all times by a parent, legal guardian, certified on-set teacher, or licensed child welfare worker.
No hazardous, age-inappropriate, or explicitly adult content exposure or participation.
On-set education: Typically three hours per workday in California, with studio teachers acting also as welfare advocates and empowered to halt production if a child’s well-being is threatened.

Despite formal protections, high-profile documentaries (e.g., “Quiet on Set: The Dark Side of Kids TV,” “Bad Influence: The Dark Side of Kidfluencers”) reveal that abuse, unsafe conditions, and even sexual exploitation still occur, catalyzing renewed union and legislative calls for mandatory background checks, transparent reporting processes, and free mental health support during and after employment.

Family, Social, and Financial Impact: Hidden Burdens

Family Dynamics and Breadwinner Pressures

Role reversals and dependency plague many families of child actors. Young stars often become the primary earners, supporting parents and siblings long before reaching adulthood. This reversal frequently disrupts traditional authority structures, erodes boundaries between child and caregiver, and can foster deep resentment or loss of self-agency.

Famous cases like Macaulay Culkin, Drew Barrymore, and Melissa Joan Hart illustrate painful lessons: estrangement, abuse, and even legal emancipation often follow when a child’s earnings become a family’s only lifeline. Psychologists warn of profound consequences—vulnerability, financial illiteracy, and cycles of abuse—when children are tasked with adult-sized responsibility and constantly at risk of betrayal by the very people meant to protect them.

Socialization and Identity

For many, the emotional toll of navigating adult spheres while missing out on childhood’s natural growth, peer bonds, and private mistakes engenders an abiding sense of “otherness.” Bullying, isolation, and an inability to trust are all too common. Genuine friendships, mentorship, and safe adult support systems are essential determinants of whether a child actor thrives post-fame.

Support Systems, Success Stories, and Paths to Recovery

The bleakness of the above narrative is not the full story; many child actors, with strong support systems and purposeful agency, have transitioned to successful adult lives—within or outside the entertainment industry. Protective factors include:

Supportive, non-dependent parents: Parents who prioritize the child’s well-being and independence over personal gain can be the single greatest bulwark against industry harms.
Consistent education and life skills: Actors like Emma Watson and the Olsen twins demonstrate that prioritizing academics and diversifying skills provides critical resilience.
Mental health resources: Increasingly, productions now provide on-set therapy, confidential reporting, and culturally competent wellness programs. Notably, former stars such as Alyson Stoner now use their platforms to provide science-based trauma recovery and industry reform advocacy.
Strong industry mentorship and union representation: Union-driven programs like SAG-AFTRA’s “Looking Ahead” provide education, counseling, and peer support for young performers. Veteran actors mentoring “the next generation” fosters healthy modeling and transition skills.

Table: Examples of Child Stars Overcoming Adversity

Name	Early Challenge	Path to Recovery/Success
Drew Barrymore	Addiction, family	Emancipation, therapy, production career, advocacy
Macaulay Culkin	Parental abuse	Legal financial control, creative pursuits, family reconciliation
Alyssa Milano	Peer pressure	Completed transition, activism, career reinvention
Selena Gomez	Anxiety, illness	Advocacy, philanthropy, launching Rare Impact Fund
Daniel Radcliffe	Typecasting, alcohol	Sought therapy, diverse roles, candid mental health contributions

Success, for many, comes not from continued stardom but from self-determination, advocacy, and a conscious break from damaging cycles.

Emerging Reforms and Hope for a New Generation

Legislative and Industry Innovations

The last five years have seen unprecedented momentum in legislative advocacy and reform, sparked by the convergence of heightened child protection awareness, the testimony of former stars, and the unique challenges of the digital age. Key areas of ongoing reform include:

Extending trust account and labor protections to social media and digital creators (kidfluencers).
Closing jurisdictional gaps between state and federal law via proposed federal Coogan-style regulations.
Mandating background checks and safety protocols in all productions involving minors—union and non-union, scripted and unscripted.
Enforcing robust education, training, and certification for on-set teachers, welfare workers, and guardians.
Establishing minimum mental health, play, and recreation standards, as well as post-employment wellness checks.
Empowering children—with formal rights—including the ability to remove online content, contest contracts, or report abuse anonymously.

Industry-Led Best Practices

Unions and advocacy organizations are responding to calls for change, investing in research, creating new reporting/whistleblowing tools, and rolling out training for all industry adults. Model contracts, union arbitration, and new funding streams for psychological services are all on the rise.

Actionable Solutions: Pathways for a Safer, Healthier Future

Building upon the lessons—both cautionary and hopeful—of the past century, industry stakeholders, lawmakers, parents, and performers themselves must share responsibility for shaping the future:

For Legislators and Industry Regulators

Standardize minimum child performer trust requirements nationwide, closing state-level loopholes.
Extend labor, education, and financial protections to all monetized child content, whether traditional or digital/social media.
Expand and enforce on-set requirements for certified educators, mental health professionals, and third-party welfare advocates.

For Unions and Professional Organizations

Prioritize transparent reporting, background checks, and impartial investigation of all complaints regarding harm to minors.
Fund peer-mentoring programs and post-career transition support.
Collaborate internationally to harmonize protections for child actors worldwide.

For Parents and Guardians

Pursue active financial recordkeeping and transparent communication with children about their earnings and career.
Set clear boundaries between parental and managerial roles; seek third-party fiduciaries if necessary.
Prioritize normalcy: time for play, school, peer interaction, and activities outside the entertainment realm.

For Producers and Agencies

Apply child-first policies in all contracts, casting, and production planning, even where not legally mandated.
Employ only certified on-set teachers and welfare workers; involve parents productively but establish non-negotiable safety and education protocols.
Commit to informed consent and autonomy for child artists, including for social media projects.

For Child Performers

Seek trusted adult allies; recognize that seeking support is a sign of strength, not weakness.
Maintain educational focus and cultivate skills beyond entertainment.
Know your legal rights, and don’t hesitate to reach out to unions or mental health organizations proactively.

Lessons from the Spotlight: From Plight to Promise

The journey of child actors in the entertainment world reveals profound truths about power, vulnerability, and hope. The industry’s past is replete with stories of heartbreak, loss, and recovered selfhood; its present a crossroads of reform and responsibility. But its future need not be a repetition of pain. With continued advocacy, legislative courage, parental commitment, and peer-driven mentorship, a new generation of young performers can inherit not just Hollywood’s thrill, but its promise of dignity, respect, and authentic childhood.

References

Rogers, Ailbhe. “More Than Pocket Money: A History of Child Actor Laws.” In Custodia Legis, 2022.
U.S. Department of Labor. “Child Entertainment Laws As of January 1, 2023.” WHD State Labor Laws, 2023.
Mazinjanin, Zeljka. “Realities of the Entertainment Industry in the USA: Child Performers and Their Right to Education.” Humanium, 2024.
Zapanta, Sophia. “10 Child Stars Who Turned Their Lives Around.” Illumeably, 2025.
Barosy, Chloe, and Baumel, Alyssa. “Behind the Spotlight: Navigating the Legal Landscape for Child Actors’ Rights in the Wake of ‘Quiet on Set’.” Brooklyn Sports & Entertainment Law Blog, 2024.
Hollywood Connections Center. “The Challenges of Being a Child Actor.” Hollywood Connections, 2025.
Malik, Ijaz. “13 Child Stars with Anxiety: The Emotional Toll of Growing Up Famous.” Our Mental Health, 2023.
U.S. Department of Labor. “Child Entertainment Laws As of January 1, 2023.” WHD State Labor Laws, 2023.
The Playground Acting Conservatory. “Building a Support System for Your Child Actor.” The Playground, 2024.
Sheridan, Peter. “Hollywood’s First Family: The Children Stars of the Silent Movies.” Express, 2017.
Young Hollywood Hall of Fame. “Child Stars & Teen Idols Silent Film Artists 1920’s.”
Rigoletto, Sandra. “The Silver Screen – A Chronicle of Stardom, Film, and the Culture of Hollywood.” 2022.
Wikipedia. “California Child Actor’s Bill.”
Ayalon, Danielle. “Minor Changes: Altering Current Coogan Law to Better Protect Children Working in Entertainment.” UC Law SF Communications and Entertainment Journal, 2013.
BizParentz Foundation. “Trust Accounts.” 2024.
CSG South. “From Likes to Laws: State Legal Protections for Child Influencers.” 2024.
U.S. Department of Labor. “Child Entertainment Laws As of January 1, 2023.” WHD State Labor Laws, 2023.
OnAssemble. “What Every Producer Should Know About Child Actor Laws.” 2023.
eCFR. “29 CFR 570.125 — Actors and performers..”
Employment Law Handbook. “FLSA Child Labor Law Exceptions.” 2023.
Cornell Law School. “29 CFR § 570.125 – Actors and performers..”
Balan, Duygu. “Smile for the Camera: The Psychological Toll of Child Fame.” Psychology Today, 2025.
NeuroLaunch Editorial Team. “Child Actors: Psychological Impact of Early Fame.” NeuroLaunch, 2024.
Yasar, Zeynep. “The Psychology of Child Actors.” BPS, 2025.
Mazinjanin, Zeljka. “Realities of the Entertainment Industry in the USA: Child Performers and their Right to Education.” Humanium, 2024.
Carmichael, Phillip. “Do Kid Actors Go to School?.” Acting Magazine, 2025.
Padilla, Chris. “Supporting Child Actors‘ Education.” ExpertBeacon, 2024.
Casano, Ann. “12 Child Stars Who Supported Their Family Talk About Being The Breadwinner.” Ranker, 2024.
NYCastings. “Behind the Curtain: What Families of Child Actors Go Through.” NYCastings, 2024.
Rodriguez, Karla. “Many Can’t Deal with the Level of Attention: Family Financial Issues.” Complex, 2024.
Rogers, Ailbhe. “More Than Pocket Money: A History of Child Actor Laws.” Library of Congress, 2022.
Bronstad, Amanda. “Coogan Law Loophole Leaves Child Actors at Financial Risk.” National Law Journal Online, 2011.
Winckler, Charlotte B. “Kidfluencers: How the Law’s Failure to Keep Up Leaves Children At Risk.” Charleston Law Review, 2020.
Guerra, Joe. “Child Actor Laws, Explained.” Backstage, 2024.
Looper. “Rules Child Actors Have to Follow.” Looper, 2024.
SetHero. “Working with Child Actors: Rules and Regulations for Film Sets.” SetHero, 2024.
CSG South. “From Likes to Laws: State Legal Protections for Child Influencers.” CSG South, 2024.
Travis, Michelle. “Netflix Doc Reveals Risks to Kid Stars, As States Gut Child Labor Laws.” Forbes, 2025.
Rosenblatt, Kalhan. “Efforts to Protect Child Influencers Will Continue to Ramp Up in 2024.” NBC News, 2023.
OurMental.Health. “13 Child Stars Who Battled Anxiety Under the Spotlight.” OurMental.Health, 2023.
Olson, Cathy Applefeld. “Mind Reading: Alyson Stoner’s Current Act Is All About Protecting Child Entertainers.” Forbes, 2025.
City of Alexandria. “Resources for Child & Youth Mental Health.” City of Alexandria, 2024.
OurMental.Health. “From Fame to Fall: Drew Barrymore’s Battle with Depression and Substance Abuse.” OurMental.Health, 2024.
Hryhoriv, Halyna. “Macaulay Culkin’s Stardom: From Child Star to Family Man.” New-York-Trend, 2025.
Popular Timelines. “Rise to Success: Career Highlights of Macaulay Culkin.” Popular Timelines, 2024.
U.S. Department of Labor. “Child Entertainment Laws As of January 1, 2023.” WHD State Labor Laws, 2023.
ITIF. “Kidfluencers Recast Spotlight on Children’s Rights in Digital Entertainment.” ITIF, 2023.
Federal Communications Law Journal. “A Star Is Born: Lack of Income Rights for Entertainment’s Newest Stars—KidTubers.” FCLJ, 2023.
Travis, Emlyn. “SAG-AFTRA Responds to Calls for More Child Actor Safety Protocols.” Entertainment Weekly, 2024.
Minor Performer Alliance. “Rules & Laws — Minor Performer Alliance.” Minor Performer Alliance, 2023.
SAG-AFTRA Foundation. “Young Performers Handbook by SAG-AFTRA.” SAG-AFTRA, 2020.
StudioBinder. “Child Actor Labor Laws.” StudioBinder, 2022.
Wrapbook. “Child Actor Labor Laws.” Wrapbook, 2023.
Roth, Murray A. “What Filmmakers Need to Know About Employing Child Actors.” Murray Roth, 2025.

Get Stories That Match Your Curiosity

Subscribe to the Infinity Gent newsletter and choose the categories that inspire you most.

Infinity Gent

The Plight of Child Actors: Challenges, Reforms, and Hope in the Entertainment Industry